A possible future without Net Neutrality

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,
Categories: electronic culture
Hits for this post:179
Tiny URL: http://r-echos.net/lk/11643
Thursday, November 8th, 2007 at 1:37 am
Bookmark on del.icio.us | Twitter This Stumble This

A possible future without Net Neutrality

It sounds pessimistic, i know - but facing reality is sometimes good to draw a better future:

The internet as we know it is about to die.

To make it short and simple: net neutrality is the fact that any information transiting on the network is equal to any other. This simple principle ensure people that no information would be considered pre-eminent by any of the internet gatekeeper. You can read a better definition of the Net Neutrality on Wikipedia

This simple principle is at risk.

There has been some warning since the early 2000’s - some said it was not relevant, some said it was… but let’s face it: big organisation want to be the gate keeper of the internet - what could possibly stop them from doing discrimination? People reaction, of course. But we can see day after day that such political action is far from reaching its own set goals.

And what if net neutrality was not going to be the decisive topic of the next us elections (there is a very few chances that this notion of neutrality grab the mind of the average american) - is there really a front here in Europe which could politically oppose such move (and understand it)?
What would be left to normal people?
More important: how would we be able to rebuild what would have been destroyed?

The only alternative I can see today has been suggested last night; there was a meeting of Node London at Gasworks and someone was speaking of the implementation of a wireless alternative to the wired internet as we know it.
No tips on by who or how this global wireless network would be run - but the suggestion just caught my attention and my imagination for the rest of the meeting and a part of the night.

netneutrality-31102007(002).jpg

Here is the picture as I imagine it - this is simply a very basic scenario and is intently thought provoking:
Wireless technology let us set-up had-hoc network for a very cheap price. More and more machines comes with descent software allowing their user to share documents on a local network - simply put: running an Apache server is a few click away on an OS X machine, for example, and most Windows are coming their IIS server.
From that point we could perfectly imagine super local network, with content you would provide to your immediate neighbours, and little by little to their neighbours, and theirs, and theirs, and theirs…
Cities could be connected just by the good will of people - actually not sharing something they are paying for, but sharing a connection to someone else. And also the content could be very handpicked in the sense that it is addressed in a more tangible manner to people they know.

Of course it sounds quite irrealistic technically at the moment, but…
How would IP addresses be assigned? Also there would be geographic gaps; it’s easy in a big urban area to imagine such a high density of nodes that it could cover a whole city and why not its suburbs - of course in rural parts it would be harder to connect the dot and make a descent grid.Nonetheless I can remember some experiments in Lausanne, Switzerland were creating network bridge over hills (up and down could be the second name of Lausanne) on quite big distance… I guess there’s not only in Lausanne that people are crossing geographical gaps with wireless network.

Let’s also consider the experience gained by P2P developer’s in the fields of had-hoc networking; if a few people could get their hands on such a project - it could be a nice alternative to the internet.

Future is bright and it finally doesn’t have to be Orange.

The concept is not new and has many echoes in the network history; lots of people have thought on this for quite a long time and Pierre kindly suggested a few links:

Wireless Mesh Network which examines more precisely the feasibility of such had-hoc network on a large scale.

Net Equality is an organisation in the US which aim is to provide ‘free internet access for low-income communities. We provide planning, deployment resources and internet mesh products worldwide and install free network hardware in qualified communities in the Pacific Northwest.

It’s also the topic of a novel by C. Doctorow, “Someone Comes to Town, Someone leaves Town” -you can download it from: http://craphound.com/someone/download.php

(Via jerome’s shared items in Google Reader.)

Related Posts




Comments are closed.

R-Echos

Subscribe in a reader




R-Echos context

Collections

* at the occasion of R-Echos issue 1 we organised some pages into topic oriented piles:

  • Displaying
  • un-Realisation
  • Physical Interface
  • Augmented Reality
  • Publishing
  • Geometry
  • Visualisation
  • Open Source Mobile Phone
  • Fab


  • Since 2004, R-Echos is an experimental online magazine dedicated to republication; topics vary from biology to graphic design, from ecology to business. It agglomerates anything which is about art, computing, science. His form is made out of collages of texts, links, images, references, videos and sounds - choosen with care to take part to this very personnal publication.



  • About
  • Articles
  • Beta version
  • Categories
  • Defragmentation
  • Directory
  • Fab
  • Index
  • Links
  • Monthly Archives
  • Open Source Mobile Phone
  • R-Echos issue 1
  • Somewhere else
  • Tags
  • Visual Index
  • Visualisation


  • Search R-Echos



    * curation / edition / selection is made by Electronest

    On Purpose: Design Concepts

    On Purpose: Design Concepts

    On Purpose: Design Concepts looks at conceptual design practices, the emergence of ‘meta design’, and the question of who or what can define something as design…
    With Åbäke, Droog Design, Daniel Eatock, Electronest, Ann-Sofie Back, Will Holder, Peter Jensen, Onkar Kular & Noam Toran, Metahaven, Alex Rich, Savage, Yuri Suzuki
    September 13 - [...]

    websites and White Cubes

    websites and White Cubes

    Dumb sign, originally uploaded by blackbeltjones.
    Been asked to work on the nominations for designs of the year again at the Design Museum, which is very nice.But it leads me back to this hoary old question – how should interactive work best be shown in a museum or gallery context? Should it be [...]

    R-Echos issue 1 - AMP001

    R-Echos issue 1

    An experiment in the economics of production: how can we shift focus from consumption of a finished product to investment in the processes of design, print & production?

    This is a poster and a text: an analog R-Echos
    Would you be interested in investing in the tangible production of this work?
    1. You can download the digital archive
    and [...]

    What if, VACANT LOT, Hoxton, London

    What if, VACANT LOT, Hoxton, London

    Related PostsBuilding and designing Digitalism’s IdealisticPaper Circuitssub-studio design blog: Herzog and de Meuron Parisian PyramidThe best CNC project machines - Hack a Daygreenpix zero-energy massive LED displayDIY Blubber BotBotanicalls Twitter DIYBuild Your Own War Bot - Wired How-To WikiHOW TO - Embroider digital imagesThe Shipyard ReturnsBottoms Up DoorbellThey [...]

    magazines as objects exhibition

    Colophon events this week

    Colophon events this week

    There are a couple of Colophon-related events in Europe this week. First up, Andrew Losowsky – that’s him above next to a copy of IsNotMagazine – has curated an exhibition of magazines as objects in Milan. CR Blog has an in-depth report with details – it sounds great, lots of magazine-y-ness. Andrew’s [...]



    R-Echos has its own tiny url system:

    * tiny url are url you can copy/paste into email without the risk of having a long line that surely will get broken and a link unusable.

    To get updates via email:

    mailinglist delivered via FeedBurner



    free advertising network